I’d posted a bass guitar on Marketplace for $120. I’d checked it out end to end, checked every fret for level from E to G then polished the frets with rouge and a dremel tool; filed nut slots down to spec (they’re always too high), set the relief and verified the truss rod and truss rod nut were good.

I checked every screw – tuner key screws, strap button screws, bridge screws, etc. for snugness and filled and redrilled a couple of stripped screw holes.

After cleaning and polishing, I installed, stretched and tuned a new set of good strings; set string height to specs, then set intonation.

Finally, I took photos and posted the ad online. One of the responses to that ad was from a fellow offering $90, which was $30 less than the $120 asking price and just $15 over what I’d paid for the guitar, not counting the new strings.

Now, here’s how I feel about “haggling”. If it’s a vintage guitar with collector value, we can certainly debate the value. If it’s an expensive guitar, say $1500 or something, maybe there’s fifty dollars or so of “room”. But if I’m selling a guitar in the neighborhood of $100 – a guitar I’ve done a $60 setup on (I setup every guitar before selling) and put new strings on, etc. My purpose is to provide the best guitar possible at the lowest price I can. I’m not trying to “rip off” anyone, so I don’t pack extra profit into my price – I’m selling as low as I can so I can buy another and “play” with it.

Naturally, I declined the offer. He countered with $100. I declined. Two days later, I got a message from the same person, asking if he could bring a guitar for me to look at. I said “Sure.”

Why can’t sellers clean their guitars???

Well, he’d bought the bass guitar in these photos, and it was buzzing “a bit” and wanted to know how much I’d charge to fix it.

I looked it over (filthy!) and saw that there was zero relief. In fact, there was a slight back bow, and string height was about right – for a Strat, not for a bass!

With a flashlight, I looked into the truss rod hole and saw metal shavings and a partially rounded hex screw. Some pickup adjustment screws were way out but the pickup was still too low, which indicated that the underlying foam needed replacing.

The nut slots were cut way too low so that no matter if everything else was fine, open strings would buzz on the first fret, and the nut was chipped and needed replacing.

Slots too low and chipped at G end

Too bad. The guitar looked nice otherwise. I had to tell the guy that a setup ($60) plus the price of a nut would have covered everything and ended up with him having a decent guitar if not for the truss rod issue.

If the nut or threads were stripped, there would be extra charges for extraction and replacement and if the nut couldn’t be removed due to stripped threads, the guitar was not likely worth repairing.

With that, he said, “I should have listened to you, but I thought if I couldn’t haggle the price down, I wouldn’t be getting a good deal.”

He said he paid $100 for this guitar. Now, he was looking at about another $100 to make it playable with a big chance that it couldn’t be fixed at all.

Underlying foam has dried out

We arranged a trade, where I took his guitar, basically for parts and credited him $40 toward the $120 guitar he’d initially inquired about. So that $120 guitar cost him $100 – $40 + $120 = $180 !

I did get the truss nut to turn but the threads were stripped and it could not be removed. That did remove much of the stress on the neck and a less scrupulous dealer could make it play ok and sell the guitar, but the next time it needed adjustment, the buyer would be out of luck. I will not sell the guitar with this neck.

I’ll have to replace the neck but I can use this one for a practice neck for when I want to try and remove the fretboard and replace the truss rod.

So, I didn’t come out so good either. I got some $10 tuner keys (wholesale value), $10 pickups and another body (I’m accumulating a box full of guitar bodies!) worth about zero to me, but let’s say $20 value – a break even deal if I ever need the body.

But I did gain a customer who is likely to refer people to me in the future.

Used guitars are not commodities. Not all guitars of a certain make, model and year are worth the same. Condition is a HUGE factor. Brand-new guitars on the shelves need a setup and 96% of them won’t get one. Things can only go downhill from there.

Why buy a guitar that is uncomfortable to play, won’t play right and will never give the right notes fretted up and down the fretboard?

The moral of this story, kids – is if you encounter an old man who refurbishes instruments just for the love of the instruments and because he prefers to see people playing or learning on decent guitars, if he’s willing to stand behind the guitar; the guitar plays great and the price looks fair – it just might be a better deal than the “great deal” garage sale guitars out there! 🙂

Not So Fast!

Later, I decided to remove the fretboard and repair or replace the truss rod and/or nut. Everything went well and I’m about to reattach the neck and setup the guitar. Stay tuned for pix and more info!